Although corporate attorney Alaina Montgomery's friends have been trying to set her up with "the right man" for years, they've been failing miserably-and this time turns out to be no exception. Alaina meets up with Dylan Harrison-a single dad who runs a bar and bait shop-en route to a masquerade party. But their costumes must have been too good, because the cops believe Alaina and Dylan are prostitute and client. The next thing Alaina and Dylan know, they're together-in jail. Discussing the situation, the two "criminals" decide to get back at their matchmakers by pretending to be a real couple-but neither expects their feigned feelings to transform into reality.